I would prefer a different functioning of the hide and show sidebar button: when hiding the sidebar the family view window should take up that place i.e. enlarge.
I agree, the implementation seems the wrong way round to me.
Agreed. The current behavior is more like a drawer attached to the side of the window rather than a pane within it. In my brief survey of other applications, I couldn't find another one that behaves like the Reunion 10 sidebar. On the other hand, there are quite a few that maintain the window size and expand the main content when the sidebar is hidden: iCal's reminder list, Mail's mailbox list, Preview's page thumbnails, Safari's reading list, and Automator's library panel. (Note that these are all left-side sidebars.)
As I was playing with the sidebar just now, I came across a bug (or perhaps "quirk" would be a better word). Show the sidebar. Resize the window so it is quite wide, then resize the sidebar wide as well. In my case, this is my default window position: the window fills about 3/4 of the width of my 27" screen, with the sidebar wide enough to show the longest name in my file (with birth and death appended). Next, hide the sidebar. Resize the window to its minimum width, then option-click the "show sidebar" button. The sidebar reappears at its former width, making the content area super-narrow. That's part 1 of the quirk. Next, use the splitter to resize the sidebar. As soon as you start to resize, the content area snaps to its usual minimum size, shrinking the sidebar in the process.
I really like the way Mail's mailboxes sidebar works in this regard. If you resize a mail window narrower (with the sidebar shown), as you pass the minimum content width, the message list column begins to narrow. When it too reaches its minimum width, Mail will narrow the Mailboxes sidebar. If you continue to narrow the window, the sidebar will reach its minimum width as well, at which time the sidebar will automatically be hidden. If you then show the sidebar again with the window at its minimum width, Mail resizes the window to the smallest size that can contain the content, the sidebar, and the message list (without violating any of their usual minima).
Comment